W Weekly

Where the buffalo-head nickels roam

Greed and capitalism at its best in American Buffalo

By Saraya Brewer
STAFF WRITER

When David Mamet’s play American Buffalo premiered to Chicago audiences in 1975, it saw no shortage of dropped jaws. Whether the audiences were squirming uncomfortable in their seats due to the free-flowing obscenities and brash portrait of American capitalism, or just reeling in the shock that somebody had finally taken the art of theater language to a new level, the sense that they were experiencing something new was unanimous. Though the shock of gritty realism and the repetition of the f-bomb in live theater has considerably died down in the last 30 years, next week Lexington will have the chance to experience the theatrical gem that is
American Buffalo at Natasha’s Café.

“American Buffalo is one of those plays that helped change the American theater landscape,” says director Eric Seale. “ In the 70s especially, people wanted theater to be this charming, cute escapism of musicals and sweet stories, and you know, everything wraps up nicely in the
end.”

Playwright Mamet, whose repertoire includes Sexual Perversity in Chicago and Glengarry Glen Ross, definitely doesn’t concern himself with sweetness or comforting resolution. American Buffalo takes place in a Chicago junk shop, and follows three small-time crooks as they plot to rob a coin collector, all the while justifying their actions as legitimate business in the name of capitalism and free enterprise. Shop owner Donny (played by Kody Kiser) enlists his teenaged gofer, Bobby (played by 16-year-old Sayre student C. G. Niquette), to steal back a valuable buffalo-head nickel he recently sold, after realizing the nickel was possibly worth a lot more than the $90 he got from it. Once his down-on-his-luck buddy, Teach (played by Bob Singleton), catches wind of the scheme, he insists on being in on it, and the characters uncover the dark underbelly of greed and capitalism (incidentally, some of the very attributes that led to the near-extinction of the American buffalo itself…hmmm).

Singleton describes his character, the disheveled and violet-tempered Teach, as “one of those people that tries to follow at least the shadier rules of business, but without doing the 9-5 version of it. You know, you see a lot of illicit enterprises that are successful because they are run well from a business sense, they’re just unethical, or violent, or illegal, or all of the above.” Since Robert Duvall’s portrayal of Teach in the 1977 Broadway version of the play, theatergoers have seen performances of this character by Al Pacino, William H. Macy (who also played Bobby in the play’s first production), and Sex in the City’s Chris North.While Mamet’s characters, however deplorable they may be, inevitably precede the plot, it’s his pioneering use of language that puts Buffalo on the map as a modern American classic. The characters talk, well, exactly how you would expect uneducated, inner-city Chicago drifters to
talk. That is, not very nice, and not always in complete sentences. (Singleton likens the language to the dialogue in such films as Dog Day Afternoon or Pulp Fiction.) Though the script, which the cast follows absolutely verbatim, poses a challenge for actors to read and interpret, the result is refreshingly effective and realistic for audiences. The language is very street, but it follows a certain rhythm as well.

“Mamet should be known as a language playwright,” Seale said, “not because he uses obscenity sometimes in his work, which is why they call him that, but because he writes really amazing language. It has a sort of cadence to it. He took iambic pentameter and he kind of turned it on its ear.”

Fortunately for the crew, the Balagula Theatre at Natasha’s Café, with the exposed brick wall and barred windows behind the stage, lends itself nicely to the set of a Chicago shop. Because it’s not exactly set up as a theater venue, the space can often pose a challenge to the cast and crew of a play.

“But that’s also one of the reasons I keep doing stuff here, it’s a lot more interesting to try,” says Seale, who’s worked extensively with Balagula Theatre since its onset. “It’s more interesting to do theater in a place that isn’t a theater, because you have to get very,
very creative and you have to use your materials very, very well.” The play runs from Nov. 14-17 at Natasha’s Café, located in Lexington at 112 Esplanade. All performances begin at 8 p.m., and admission is $7. Dinner during the performance is optional. For reservations or more
information, call 259-2754.

(On a side note, Black Diamond, the buffalo rumored to be the model for the original Buffalo nickel in 1913, was sold to a meat-packing company a couple of years after the debut of the coin. Despite public efforts to save him, but in line with free enterprise, the company went on to
produce delicious meat patties known as Black Diamond steaks. Mmmmmm!)

Current Production          Previous Productions          Surprise Theatre