The History of "Surprise Theatre"

“Surprise Theatre” is the culmination of the “intimate theatre” idea that developed over three years of doing theatre at Natasha’s. One-act plays hidden in restaurant service with no advertisement of story or cast, intending to “spring up” suddenly during an evening of dining taking their audience off guard first occurred in July 2005.

The concept of embedded theatre was extremely attractive to owners Gene and Natasha Williams and stimulated their thinking not only about how to use the space creatively, but how to take “intimate theatre” into a new direction. Partly its origins could be traced to “theatre friendly” restaurants in New York City that they had visited over the years. These restaurants were staffed with so many actors that servers would break into Broadway Show Tunes for musicals running at the time as advertising teasers. But before "Surprise Theatre" came into existence, there was just plain old provocative and intellectually entertaining theatre combined with Natasha's regular dinner service. In the beginning it was just called “Balagula Dinner Theatre” and which set out not to be your standard “bell, book, and candle whodunit? dinner theatre." The owners and original founders of The Balagula Theatre decided that the foremost agenda of their theatre should be to provoke thought as well as entertain. To utilize to the fullest the in house talent of artistic individuals who made up the restaurant staff and creatively make the most of the restaurant space itself.

The Balgula’s first production Kissing Christine premiered April 30th 2003 featuring Joe Gatton, Anitra Brumagen, and Kim Dixon. This story of two strangers getting to know each other on a blind date set the tone for future productions of intimate theatre.  The Balagula Theatre would follow this concept in future plays they produced such as Phyro Giants!, Accidental Death of an Anarchist, and Death and the Maiden.

The Balagula Theatre also hosted productions created outside the business in need of a space to perform and after hosting a production of Neil Labute’s Bash Gene & Natasha tapped some of those performers (Tamara Bentley, Edmund Desiato, and Eric Ryan Seale) to help create the first ever night of “Surprise Theatre.”

The initial “noble experiment” of “Surprise Theatre” took place as part of the four day celebration to honor Natasha’s Café successful four year anniversary downtown. The idea of hosting several evenings of one-act plays although formed over time, now was assembled in just over a week. Three shows were chosen by critically acclaimed playwright David Ives from his collections “All in the Timing” and “Time Flies.”

Rich Copley’s review in the Lexington Hereld-Leader which came out on the final night of “Surprise Theatre” packed in the audience and showed a demand to extend the run, although schedules never allowed for any more performances the idea to do more nights of “Surprise” stuck around. (Read Review)

In August of 2005 Gene and Natasha Williams made Eric Ryan Seale Artistic Director of “Surprise Theatre” and decided to create a brand which would deliver monthly events with each month featuring new installments. The idea was to build on the initial concept continuing to utilize the in-house talent of the employees as well as bring in actors from Lexington’s theatre scene.

“Surprise Theatre” kicked off its official inauguration on December 15th & 16th 2005 with another evening of one-acts by David Ives.

This run also showed the need to add more dates and led to an encore performance on New Year’s Eve of Degas, C’est Moi and Dr. Fritz (with Eric Ryan Seale replacing Nathaniel Barrett who was unable to attend).

Back